Back in June this year, I had written a post on Mapletree North Asia Commercial Trust (MNACT) in my “Inside The Bedokian’s Portfolio” series (see here). In it, I had mentioned about the crown jewel Festival Walk, a large retail and office property situated in Hong Kong, and itself was a prime concern due to the huge concentration in MNACT’s book value and revenue, which both stood at about 60-plus percent.
Last week, Festival Walk had sustained internal damages that warranted a full closure, after it was being targeted by protestor groups in the current unrest. With reopening, we are not very sure whether it may be subjected to further damages. This definitely has a huge impact in retail revenue from shoppers, which in turn rental revenue from Festival Walk tenants and eventually dividends to MNACT unitholders.
I had made an extensive analysis and prognosis of the Hong Kong situation, given the social, geo-political and economy factors, the whole thing may not end quick, and even so, there may still be underlying tensions simmering for another one. Hence, in view of my conclusion above (I could be wrong, though, so please do your own due diligence), I had fully divested MNACT.
It is not really a loss as I had entered at SGD 0.91 back in August 2014 and there were still some capital gains despite my second tranche (which was two-thirds number of units of the first one) of SGD 1.41 added in July 2019. Adding in dividends, it was about 9.8% annualized.
Every moment is a learning opportunity, so using this real-life situation, let me provide some pointers to you as takeaways.
Takeaway #1: Rebalancing The Portfolio, The “Wishlist” And Averaging Strategies
As of 15 November 2019, MNACT stood at about 4.8% of our Bedokian Portfolio in value. The divestment meant an addition of 4.8% to the cash portion and a drop of the same percentage points from our REITs asset class, which is a substantial deviation from the strategic allocation. Therefore, rebalancing has to be done on our Bedokian Portfolio and I would redeploy this capital as soon as possible. This is where the “wishlist” comes in useful.
As mentioned in my ebook, the “wishlist” is a shortlist of financial instruments and investment vehicles (of the various asset classes) that you came up with on a cursory basis1. It also serves as a “what’s next to enter?” guide. Besides the “wishlist”, you could also employ averaging strategies (up or down) on your existing holdings (see here on my post on averaging).
Takeaway #2 – What Price To Reenter?
MNACT, in my opinion, still has potential, but not at this moment. Besides Festival Walk, it has eight other properties; two in mainland China and six in Japan. The next question would be: What price to reenter?
The most simplistic (and worst-case scenario) to determine the price would be to discount the entire net asset value (NAV) of Festival Walk, which is 66% based on the latest property valuation as at 31 March 20192. With MNACT’s NAV of SGD 1.43 as at 30 Sep 20193, it means the price would be around SGD 0.48. The chance of the price going down that low is remote, though it is not impossible.
There are other valuation methods for REITs, such as funds from operations, dividend yield, etc. As I had stated here, pricing and valuation is very subjective depending on the methodologies used, so stick to a method that works best for you.
Takeaway #3 – Looking Beyond
True that at this price, MNACT’s yield stood at about 6.7%, but all dimensions must be factored in before a sound transaction decision is made. The Bedokian Portfolio’s three-tier fundamental analysis model4 (financial statements, environmental factors and economic conditions) covered most aspects and angles required while looking at a REIT (or company) as it looks beyond just the usual ratios and numbers.
On top of economics, we need to consider also the social, political and even natural variables, for these do really play a part on how and where your investments are heading. Therefore, it is important to look beyond.
1 – The Bedokian Portfolio, p94-95
2, 3 – Mapletree North Asia Commercial Trust, Financial Results for the Period from 1 April 2019 to 30 September 2019. https://www.mapletreenorthasiacommercialtrust.com/~/media/MNACT/Newsroom/Announcements/2019/Oct/MNACT_PresentationSlides__2QFY1920.pdf (accessed 20 Nov 2019)
4 – The Bedokian Portfolio, p84-85